Do you dream about gooey, melt-in-your-mouth, freshly baked cookies that make your taste buds dance? Well, my friend, you’ve come to the right place. Toronto is the city of delicious treats, and when it comes to cookies, there’s no shortage of options.
But with so many places to choose from, how do you find the best of the best?
Fear not, because we’ve done the taste-testing for you. Join us on a mouth-watering journey as we search for Toronto’s top cookies. So grab a glass of milk and get ready to embark on a cookie adventure like no other!
Table of Contents
What makes a Great Cookie?
When it comes to finding the best cookies in Toronto, there are a few key factors that can make or break a cookie.
Texture
A great cookie should be crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. When biting into a cookie, it should have a slight resistance before yielding to a soft and tender center.
Quality of Ingredients
High-quality butter, flour, sugar, and chocolate can take a cookie from good to great. The best cookies are made with fresh, wholesome ingredients and are free from any artificial additives or preservatives.
Flavors
Whether it’s a classic chocolate chip cookie or a unique flavor combination, the flavors should be well-balanced and not overpowering. A cookie that is too sweet, too salty, or too bland can be a turn-off.
Freshness
A fresh cookie should be soft and chewy, with a crispy exterior. Stale cookies can be hard, dry, and crumbly, making them unpleasant to eat. When searching for the best cookies in Toronto, look for bakeries and cafes that bake their cookies on-site or use fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
With these factors taken into consideration, here is our top-five list of places to get the best cookies in Toronto.
| Best Cookies in Toronto | Google Rating | Google Reviews |
| Le Gourmand | 4.4 | 1,359 |
| Craig’s Cookies | 4.4 | 1,302 |
| Roselle Desserts | 4.8 | 1,036 |
| Bakerbots Baking | 4.7 | 871 |
| Home Baking Co. | 4.6 | 367 |
Where to find the Best Cookies in Toronto
Google My Maps Link:
https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/edit?mid=1R5nQZF1uH-WorTT1EvtvsYe7unXRYSY&usp=sharing
We followed the aroma of freshly baked cookies through the streets of Toronto, and here are our top five spots.
Le Gourmand
“Heavenly chocolate chip cookies”
You won’t be able to resist the aroma and taste of Le Gourmand’s freshly baked cookies. (Image source: Le Gourmand Toronto)
Our first stop is a cozy cafe in Toronto. Le Gourmand, located in the bustling Queen and Spadina area, has been serving up delicious pastries and desserts for 18 years, and their commitment to using simple recipes with high-quality ingredients shines through in their world-famous chocolate chip cookies.
Le Gourmand’s walnut and chocolate chip cookies are a must-try for any cookie lover. (Image source: Le Gourmand Toronto)
If you’re a fan of walnuts, you must try their walnut and chocolate chip cookies. They are big, soft, chewy, and packed full of chocolate chips and crunchy walnuts. These cookies at Le Gourmand have a firm texture with a softness that will leave you craving more with each bite.
The cafe has a rustic feel with wood furnishings, making it a perfect spot for a midday treat. Plus, there’s ample seating both inside and outside, so you can enjoy your cookie and coffee in any weather. Overall, Le Gourmand is an excellent cafe that won’t break the bank and is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Pricing: Cookies start at $4.99
Pros
- Nice and clean space with ample seating both inside and outside
- Staff are friendly and efficient.
- Good spot for brunch.
Cons
- Service can be slow during busy periods.
Location: 152 Spadina Ave., Toronto, ON M5V 3S6
Google Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5 (1,359 reviews)
Craig’s Cookies
“One bite and you’ll be hooked.”
Craig’s Cookies are perfect for sharing with a friend or keeping all to yourself. (Image source: Craig’s Cookies Toronto)
For a fun and delicious experience, we have Craig’s Cookies, where founder Craig Pike is constantly pushing the boundaries of flavor with over 100 unique varieties. Located in a bright, inviting store with the aroma of freshly baked cookies wafting through the air, Craig’s Cookies takes classic recipes and adds a playful twist with sweet treats like Mars bars and Easter eggs.
Innovative flavors featuring your favorite Creme Egg at Craig’s Cookies. (Image source: Craig’s Cookies Toronto)
Craig’s Cookies are known for their soft and chewy centers with crispy edges, and their perfect size makes them ideal for sharing. The innovative flavor combinations are a true standout, with chocolate bars like Kit Kats and Reese’s Pieces making appearances in the cookie dough.
Not only are the cookies absolutely delicious, but they’re also incredibly fresh – you can even enjoy them the next day without sacrificing any of the texture or flavor.
Pricing: Starts at $18.00 for half a dozen cookies
Pros
- Beautiful display of cookies.
- Innovative flavors with chocolate bars.
- Pride cookies available.
Cons
- Issues with ordering and charges.
Location: 1332 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6K 1L4
Google Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5 (1,302 reviews)
Roselle Desserts
“ Crafted with care and precision”
Each cookie at Roselle Desserts has a perfect balance of sweetness and flavor. (Image source: Roselle Desserts Toronto)
Roselle Desserts is the place to go in Toronto for truly exceptional sweet treats. With only the finest ingredients and pastry skills honed in the top kitchens of Europe and Asia, this French fusion patisserie takes great pride in its distinction.
Bite into Roselle Desserts’ cookies and experience a buttery, crumbly texture that melts in your mouth. (Image source: Roselle Desserts Toronto)
Roselle’s cookies are among the best in the city; they have a satisfyingly soft and chewy texture. You can always find something new to try thanks to their seasonal selections, but if you’re a dessert fanatic, you absolutely must try their classic shortbread cookie. It’s worth the wait to taste the delightful and irreverent local touches with each bite, even if it takes a while. Overall, Roselle Desserts is an excellent sweets shop with a lot of personalities.
Pricing: Cookies Start at $3.80
Pros
- Great quality of ingredients.
- Seasonal offerings.
- Friendly and accommodating staff
Cons
- Some desserts are overly sweet.
Location: 362 King St E, Toronto, ON M5A 1K9
Google Rating: 4.8 stars out of 5 (1,036 reviews)
Bakerbots Baking
“Perfect for any occasion”
The birthday cookie at Bakerbots Baking is something to bring to the party. (Image source: Bakerbots Baking Instagram)
Bakerbots Baking is a cool and contemporary bakery that offers an impressive array of cookies and other baked goods. Their sweets are so popular that they mostly sell out on weekends, but you might get lucky and find a small batch available during the week. What sets Bakerbots apart from other bakeries in Toronto is the consistently high quality of their baked goods, which are always moist, flavorful, and just downright delicious.
The selection of cookies and other baked goods at Bakerbots is always changing, so be sure to stop by frequently to try something new. (Image source: Bakerbots Baking Instagram)
There’s something for everyone with Bakerbots’ incredible selection of sweets and treats. Its chewy, tender interior is a welcome contrast to the crisp outside. Each cookie is baked with love and precision, guaranteeing that each of them is delicious and of the highest quality.
Pricing: Cookies start at $1.75
Pros
- Delicious baked goodies
- Friendly and welcoming staff
- Variety of treats and sweets to choose from
Cons
- There’s always a long lineup when buying
Location: 205 Delaware Ave, Toronto, ON M6H 2T4
Google Rating: 4.7 stars out of 5 (871 reviews)
Home Baking Co.
“Your guilt-free cookies”
Home Baking Co.’s circus cookie is a fun and colorful treat for any occasion. (Image source: Home Baking Co.Instagram)
Home Baking Co. is a charming bakery café located in the Toronto neighborhood of Bloordale. They have their own recipes for their cookies that have become a favorite among Toronto locals. What sets them apart is the surprisingly broad selection of baked goods for such a small space, making it the perfect spot to stop by for a quick pick-me-up.
A tray of freshly baked cookies waiting to be devoured at Home Baking Co. (Image source: Home Baking Co.Instagram)
Home Baking Co. also offers great ice cream sandwiches made with fresh-made cookies and different flavors of ice cream. One of the bestsellers is their excellent gluten-free vegan cookie, which is hard to find in many other bakeries.
Pricing: Cookies start at $1.50
Pros
- They have dairy-free and gluten-free options available.
- Surprisingly broad selection of baked goods for a small shop
- Offers ice cream sandwiches with fresh-made cookies
Cons
- Some concerns about their customer service
Location: 1242 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M6H 1N5
Google Rating: 4.6 stars out of 5 (367 reviews)
A Cookie Crawl Through Toronto
And that’s how the cookie crumbles. We hope you enjoyed this mouth-watering tour of the best cookies in Toronto. From classic chocolate chips to exotic matcha flavors, this city has something for every cookie lover out there. So why not grab a glass of milk (or your favorite non-dairy alternative) and indulge in some of Toronto’s finest baked goods?
But be warned: With so many delicious options, you may end up with a cookie addiction that only a return trip to these places can cure. Don’t say we didn’t warn you! Until next time, happy munching!